Turning Breakthroughs into Benchmarks: Measuring Success in Coaching
By Dr. Michelle Burkhard
Measuring the Intangible: A Real Story from My Coaching Practice
A few years ago, I was working with a leader, we'll call her Mary, who came to me feeling stuck. Her team was disengaged, her confidence was slipping, and she felt like she was spinning her wheels. The classic coaching setup, right?
In our first session, she said, "I just want to feel like I'm leading again." Beautiful goal… but not exactly measurable. So together, we unpacked what "leading" looked like. By the end of that session, we'd defined three tangible indicators:
Delegation
She'd delegate at least 25% more tasks.
Communication
Her team would rate communication higher in their monthly check-ins.
Confidence
She'd speak up in leadership meetings without rehearsing in her head for 10 minutes first.
Over three months, we tracked those markers, sometimes with data (like the team surveys), sometimes with honest reflection ("I actually spoke up twice today!"). The results? Her delegation increased by 40%, team satisfaction rose, and most importantly, she felt like herself again.
Here's the magic: the numbers didn't replace the transformation, they revealed it. They showed her growth in a way her inner critic couldn't argue with.
When Mary's organization asked for proof that coaching "worked," we didn't hand them a feel-good story; we showed them real progress supported by both data and heart.
And that's what I love about outcome measurement in coaching; it's not about reducing humanity to numbers. It's about giving people visible evidence of their own evolution. When clients can see their change, they start to believe in it more deeply.
That's the kind of ROI I'm in this business for: the Return on Insight.
Using Data and Metrics in Coaching
What Works (and What Really Doesn't)
Let's be honest, most of us didn't become coaches because we love spreadsheets. We love people, transformation, and those "aha" moments that make all the sticky stuff worth it. But as coaching continues to grow (and, yes, get more expensive), clients are increasingly asking one reasonable question:
"So… how will I know this actually worked?"
Fair point.
The world is becoming more data-driven, and coaching is no exception. Whether you're working with individuals, teams, or organizations, being able to measure outcomes, not just feelings, is what sets apart a good coach from a truly credible one.
Why Measurement Matters
(Even if You Cringe at the Word "Metrics")
Think of it this way: when clients invest thousands of dollars (or more), they want assurance they're not just buying "good vibes and breakthroughs." They want proof that the changes stick.
Measurement helps you:
Demonstrate ROI (Return on Investment)
so decision-makers can justify hiring you again.
Spot progress and patterns
so clients see they are changing, even when they forget how far they've come.
Fine-tune your process
so you can see which tools, questions, or frameworks actually work best.
Data doesn't have to kill the magic of coaching: it can highlight it.
What Works When Measuring Coaching Impact
Here's what's worth tracking… without turning your sessions into a science experiment:
01
Start with Clear Goals
Vague goals ("feel more confident") make vague outcomes. Instead, co-create specific, measurable targets: "Speak up in weekly team meetings 4 out of 5 times," or "Delegate at least 30% of tasks by Q3."
02
Use a Mix of Quantitative and Qualitative Data
Numbers are great, but they don't tell the full story. Combine surveys, 360-feedback, or progress trackers with client reflections and stories. Data + narrative = a richer picture of growth.
03
Track Over Time, Not Just at the End
Change doesn't always happen in a straight line. Checking in periodically helps both you and the client celebrate small wins and adjust as needed.
04
Leverage Simple Tools
No need for a corporate dashboard or NASA-level analytics. Google Forms, spreadsheets, or even a well-designed feedback form can do wonders. The key is consistency.
What Doesn't Work
A few traps to avoid (learned the hard way by many a coach):
Over-measuring
Turning your coaching practice into a data lab can drain the human element. Clients aren't lab ratsβ€”they're evolving humans.
Tracking the wrong things
Don't measure activity (number of sessions) when the goal is impact (leadership confidence, team performance, reduced turnover).
Forgetting context
Progress looks different for everyone. A "small" improvement in one area might mean huge internal change elsewhere.
The Real ROI: Return on Insight
At the end of the day, coaching ROI isn't just about money, it's about meaning. The goal is to show that your work leads to tangible improvement and lasting transformation.
When you can confidently show both the hard data ("sales increased 20%") and the soft truth ("I finally believe in my leadership"), you're not just a coach, you're a trusted growth partner.
And that's the kind of ROI no spreadsheet can fully capture.
Here are some coach(y) questions to consider:
What evidence do I currently have that my coaching truly works, and would it convince a skeptical CFO or HR director?
Am I measuring what actually matters, or just what's easiest to count?
How can I use data to deepen, not dilute, the human element of coaching?
Michelle Burkhard
Michelle Burkhard is the founder and lead coach of Grow By 1, a development company dedicated to helping leaders, teams, and organizations grow intentionally: one insight at a time. With a background in education, psychology, and leadership development, Michelle blends evidence-based coaching methods with a deeply human approach that values both measurable outcomes and meaningful transformation. As a certified growth leader and coach trainer, she has guided hundreds of professionals through programs that cultivate clarity, communication, and confidence; while grounding every breakthrough in real, trackable results. Michelle believes that the best coaching balances data and intuition: the numbers show progress, but the stories reveal the heart. Through her speaking, writing, and training, Michelle champions the idea that personal growth should be both seen and felt. Her work equips coaches and leaders alike to measure what truly matters: human change that lasts. When she’s not teaching or coaching, you’ll find her experimenting with new ideas for leadership development, recording her latest podcast episode, or enjoying good conversation over coffee (preferably with extra cream).
Advertise with The Coaches' Chronicle
Click image to discover how to place your premium ad in The Coaches' Chronicle

Amazon.com

Way of the Dragonfly: 101 Maxims for Leading a High Vibrational & Conscious Life

Way of the Dragonfly: 101 Maxims for Leading a High Vibrational & Conscious Life - Kindle edition by Carroll, Jonathan. Religion & Spirituality Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

Ways To Stay Involved…
Subscribe to The Coaches' Chronicle
Click on the image above and make sure to subscribe to 𝑻𝒉𝒆 π‘ͺ𝒐𝒂𝒄𝒉𝒆𝒔' π‘ͺπ’‰π’“π’π’π’Šπ’„π’π’† for free so you don't miss any future issues!
Submit An Article For Review
Click on the image above to submit your article. The deadline for submissions is the first Friday of the month preceding the release of the next issue.
By Nick Hampshire